Canadian Antiques Roadshow
Home button Meet our Experts button TV show button Tell me About... button Online Features button Newsletter button Helpful Info button
Section header

Determining the Authenticity of Paper

Valerie and Bill Brayley examine letterValerie: Now, this, if it’s real it’s incredible. It’s a letter written from the Titanic while it was sinking that was apparently found in a bottle. And it says, “I’m putting this in a bottle, this is not the ship of anyone’s dreams except Satan’s”. This guy, Hugo Ross, who wrote it is in fact someone who was on the Titanic. How do you tell if something like that’s real?

Bill Brayley: Well, it is tricky but there are a number of quick tests. First of all, you’ve got to have a look at it, you’ve got wrinkles in the paper here, perhaps it was rolled up. You look for some, some smudging or water has been in contact with this, there’s some staining which might be a good thing. Then, you know what, you look at the paper itself. You know, see if it’s Bill Brayley smells the letter for musthandmade paper, there’d be lines there, if there was, it’s not. So it might be just an inexpensive commercial grade, you know, turn it over, smell it and see if it’s…

Valerie: What are you smelling for?

Bill Brayley: Well, if there’s any must or anything you might be able to pick up an odour from it. So that’s kind of a quick analysis of how to do that. I was involved in appraising for the Museum of the Atlantic in Halifax, the Children’s boots, that they’d just received as a donation and as further tests, what they did, the University at Utah for DNA tests, the University of Lakehead for chemical tests and because the Titanic material is so valuable and so important and so sought after all those tests would have to be done to give you some sort of conclusive data to say that that might be a real thing.

Bill Brayley holds the letter up to the lightValerie: So you’d have to date the paper and data the ink…

Bill Brayley: Yes, exactly.

Valerie: And make sure that this wasn’t somebody’s science project with tea leaves.

Bill Brayley: Exactly. And you know, if there was some salt water in there anywhere they’d be able to pick that up possibly from the crystallization and so on and so forth. It’s amazing what can be done with something like this.

Valerie: But just looking at it you can’t tell.

A letter written by someone on the Titanic?Bill Brayley: I wouldn’t want to… it would be not the sort of thing that an appraiser would do with any sort of…

Valerie: If it’s real it is so cool.

Bill Brayley: And worth a lot of money.

Valerie: Yes.

Bill Brayley: Yes.

 

Click here to play the video clip.

or back to tv show "more information"

or to more bonus items


 

Section  links
We want to hear from you.
footer navigation bar
   
Home The TV Show Meet our Experts TV show links Tell me about... Online Features Newsletter Our Store Helpful Info Site Map Our Sponsors Contact Us CBC Roadshow Web Site Meet Valerie Pringle TV show links Broadcast Schedule Old TV show links Behind the Scenes FAQ's Our Sponsors 2005 Tour Roadshow Store CBC Roadshow web site BBC Roadshow web site PBS Roadshow web site